Ray Phoenix ([info]participant) wrote,
@ 2003-07-13 17:41:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend  Next Entry
Meowse's experience talking with young people about gayness
I started to make this a comment on his post, but realized it's a bit long for general consumption. I'm putting it here, because his post hit a nerve, and I'd like to explore it a bit further.

...What a way to make $60 (the great tug of war)...

Isn't it surprising that that kind of success doesn't insulate anyone from the kind of abuse you got later? It shows that society is ready to accept the idea that *anyone* can be gay, whether tall, short, white, black, educated, ignorant, young, or old, and a corollary should be (but isn't well recognized) that one really can't tell that much about the book from looking at the cover.

When I went to Mexico 42 years ago, I was identified as gay in Nogales. They also nicknamed me "Albeese Prayley" (Elvis) because I sang in the public square for a few minutes each of several days running as part of a Red Cross fundraiser. I did some Elvis songs, and I heard "Albeese Preyley es puto" numerous times. I never had the courage to actually confront anyone about it; now I wish I had. I think I also got accused because the people most willing to spend time with me tutoring me in exactly the right way to say "uno, dos, tres, ..." were young (10-12 year old) males, and who knows but that they looked for gay Americans for tips in their spare time? Who knows what would have happened if I had made a big thing of being, or not being, gay? In the early 60's, a person could get seriously injured over any such misunderstanding, it was easier for me to keep travelling and leave the bigots in the dust. For that matter, I might still take the same course; life is still dangerous. Imagine if you had been 5'4" and openly gay last night, and had to walk alone to your car. Hmmmm?

Wow. I guess something in your post must have struck a nerve, yes? I'll take further comments to my own journal (there is probably an unspoken rule about not cluttering up the airwaves in comments). In fact, I'm going to copy the bulk of this to my journal and leave just a pointer here.

Well, that's what I wrote, and I'm sticking to it. I need to learn more about sharing to get much more open about my past. But that's a marker.

Love,

Ray



(1 comment) - (Post a new comment)

Heh. I actually pointed out to them that I had won the tug-of-war.
[info]meowse
2003-07-13 03:35 pm UTC (link)
Their response? "Yeah, but you're GAAAAAAY!"

I think, upon reflection, that it shows that who-fucks-who is really not much of a social issue, but effeminacy is still very threatening. If I'd been walking around in a straight man's t-shirt, with no earrings and a long pony-tail (which all of the other men there were wearing, and which therefore in that cultural context would be a strong heterosexual sexual signifier), and I'd mentioned to someone that I was gay, I expect I would've gotten no reaction other than "Man, you're gay? How weird."

To poke at it from another direction, so to speak, I think I may have been tapping into the same deep well of discomfort and uncertainty that made the berdache so commonly fulfill a shaman role in traditional Native American culture. There's a power, a fascination, in people who violate our dichotomous assumptions about gender, and I think that may have been behind a lot of the strength and violence of their reactions.

Openly gay? I think there would have been far less foofaraw.

Regarding the 5'4" part of the question, though--yes, I'd have been afraid. It was comforting, knowing that if they did get physical (and some of the kids did, at various times, move their aggression to a physical level) in any serious way, I could take all twelve of them comfortably. But I think more of that comfort came from the experience and ruthlessness of age than from sheer physical size. "Old age and treachery will always defeat youth and skill," as they say. Were I 5'4", I assure you I would by this time have picked up the self-defense skills to be at least as safe as I am in this reality. And having my ass handed to me recently by a 5'3" lightly built female friend convinces me that this is entirely possible.

Thank you for your comments, especially the self-revelatory and historical ones. Your life when you were the age I am now holds an almost endless fascination for me, particularly as it is in many ways one of the lives I wish I could lead (but which Deirdre and other responsibilities preclude for me). I encourage you to continue sharing; nothing you might share from that long ago, and precious little you might share from your life now, could possibly hurt you in the real world.

And I assure you that anything you share will only increase your value to me, and to anyone who is likely to encounter you via my journal.

Oh, and you may want to edit your comment on my post to actually include a link to this post. The link URL would be http://www.livejournal.com/users/participant/4473.html, which you can derive for yourself by clicking the "comment on this" link on a post, and then stripping off the "?mode=reply" on the end of it.

(Reply to this)


(1 comment) - (Post a new comment)

Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…